12/10/06 Troops uninspired by commission's report

Submitted by WNPJ Outreach Coordinator Steve Burns

Troops uninspired by commission's report

Wisconsin State Journal
December 10, 2006

As might be expected, the wisest take on the recent Baker-Hamilton commission comes from soldiers currently serving in Iraq. None of the soldiers serving in Ramadi, interviewed for Thursday's story "Soldiers in Iraq are skeptical," drew hope from the commission's recommendations.

Consider one recommendations: to reduce U.S. "combat forces" in Iraq while rapidly increasing the number of U.S. "combat advisors" embedded with Iraqi military units. Does it make any difference to an American soldier, when he is being shot at by snipers and threatened by roadside bombs, that he is now to be considered a "combat advisor?" Doesn't this increase the danger for our troops, soon to be "embedded" with Iraqi units of doubtful loyalty?

First Lt. Gerard Dow had it right when he said of the Iraqi people, "U.S. soldiers are dying trying to help people who don't want their help."

If there had been even one participant in the Baker-Hamilton commission with Lt. Dow's common sense, they might have had the courage to come to the only conclusion that makes sense -- to bring our troops home now.

-- Steve Burns, Wisconsin Network for Peace and Justice, Madison